NEWS

admin admin

Daily Telegraph: Eamonn's letter to the Editor

Slug path
asi-in-the-news/asi-in-the-news/daily-telegraph-eamonns-letter-to-the-editor
Joomla-id
5353
Old Teaser

22 June 2010

Eamonn Butler writes to the Daily Telegraph explaining that a lower rate of Capital Gains Tax than Income Tax does not lead to widespread Income Tax avoidance.

Published in the Daily Telegraph here. 

Read More
admin admin

The Independent: Justin Byam Shaw: Risk-takers need tax breaks

Slug path
asi-in-the-news/asi-in-the-news/the-independent-justin-byam-shaw-risk-takers-need-tax-breaks
Joomla-id
5355
Old Teaser

21 June 2010

The Independent references our calculations showing that when Capital Gains Tax rates increase, the Treasury's take falls.

Published in full in The Independent here.

Read More
admin admin

Sky News: Report Warns Against Capital Gains Tax Rise

Slug path
asi-in-the-news/asi-in-the-news/sky-news-report-warns-against-capital-gains-tax-rise
Joomla-id
5362
Old Teaser

19 June 2010

Sky News reports on our warnings that an increase in Capital Gains Tax will seen a fall in tax revenues.

Published in Sky News here and on the TV news bulletin

Read More
admin admin

Coalition capital gains policy will reduce revenue by £2.48 billion

19 June 2010

According to the Adam Smith Institute this reduction in revenue is equivalent to over 30,000 public sector job losses.

In a new report the Adam Smith Institute calculates that tax revenues will fall by £2.48 billion if coalition tax policy of bringing capital gains tax rates in line with income tax rates becomes law. It points out that if the deficit is not to be widened further this reduction in revenue will be equal to 30,000 additional public sector job losses or equivalent cuts in the capital budget.

The report uses new evidence from Ireland, Sweden and Switzerland combined with existing analysis from America, Australia and Britain to identify more precisely the revenue consequences of CGT increases in the UK. It looks at both revenue losses from capital gains tax and from other taxes as a consequence of the economic damage caused by CGT rises.

Amongst the new evidence considered is the result of CGT rate changes in Ireland and Sweden. The 1997 Budget in Ireland halved the rate of capital gains tax from 40% to 20%. The then Minister for Finance, Charlie McCreevy, was heavily criticized on the grounds that this would reduce revenues. In fact revenues rose considerably, almost trebling and greatly exceeding official predictions.

The report draws together international evidence of CGT rises to show that for every 1% point increase in the CGT rates revenue will fall by 2%. This could involve a revenue loss of £880m.

The report also highlights the extent to which revenues from other taxes would be lower as a consequence of the negative effect on economic activity caused by CGT rises. Evidence from Switzerland shows that cantons which eliminated CGT had 3.1% higher growth over those that did not. Since a tax on capital reduces the amount of capital that can be formed and profitably used, the consequent lower levels of output, employment, and consumption would reduce a wide range of tax revenues. The report estimates that the effect on other tax revenues would be £1.6bn per annum.

Lastly the report addresses the fallacy that CGT rises are necessary to prevent ‘switching’ of income to lower taxed capital gains. Since only about 5% of gains come from assets held in the short-term and possibly affected by such switching, the revenue effects are negligible. Moreover, many countries with no capital gains tax such as Belgium and Hong Kong succeed in dealing with this issue.

In total the reductions in revenue that will result from the implementation of coalition capital gains policy will amount to £2.48 billion.

To put the consequences in perspective this will involve finding substantial additional cuts in public spending akin to over £30,000 public sector jobs or equivalent cuts in the capital budget.

Dr. Eamonn Butler, Director of the Adam Smith Institute, said:

“Media analysis suggests this policy has arisen as a result of a political arrangement rather than careful economic analysis. When we have a dangerously large deficit politicians must take especial care that fiscal policy measures are adopted on economic rather than political grounds. Otherwise the deficit will worsen as a result of lower growth and reduced revenues, the opposite of what is intended.”

Slug path
coalition-capital-gains-policy-will-reduce-revenue-by-p248-billion-
Joomla-id
5368
Read More
admin admin

BBC News: Government warned over CGT rise

Slug path
asi-in-the-news/asi-in-the-news/bbc-news-government-warned-over-cgt-rise
Joomla-id
5351
Old Teaser

19 June 2010

Our warning that a rise in Capital Gains Tax will cost the taxman revenue is reported on by BBC News.

Published in BBC News here.

Read More
admin admin

Daily Mail: Capital gains tax rise will 'end up losing the Treasury £2.5bn'

Slug path
asi-in-the-news/asi-in-the-news/daily-mail-capital-gains-tax-rise-will-end-up-losing-the-treasury-p25bn
Joomla-id
5350
Old Teaser

19 June 2010

Eamonn Butler comments that the decision to increase Capital Gains Tax seems to have been made as a political statement rather than as a result of economic analysis at the Daily Mail.

Published in the Daily Mail here. 

Read More

Media contact:  

emily@adamsmith.org

Media phone: 07584778207

Archive